coloured gemstones
A selection of natural coloured gemstones. Photo: Equatorial Bespoke Jewellery
City & CultureLiving Asia

Coloured Gemstones: Why Flawless Isn’t Always the Better Buy

URL copied
Share URL copied

When it comes to coloured gemstones, the most flawless stone is not always the most valuable one, and it is not always the most meaningful choice either. Colour, transparency, cut, size and treatment status all shape what a ruby, sapphire or emerald is worth. The tiny internal features known as inclusions can weaken a stone’s appeal, but they can also reveal where it came from.

For buyers, that means a clarity grade on its own tells only part of the story.

What Inclusions Reveal About Coloured Gemstones

According to the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), inclusions such as needles, crystals and fluid pockets help gemologists identify a stone, assess its possible origin and separate natural material from synthetic or treated gems.

In other words, what looks like a flaw can be evidence. In some natural coloured gemstones, it is even part of what makes the stone exceptional.

coloured gemstones
A selection of natural coloured gemstones. Photo: Equatorial Bespoke Jewellery

Why the Question Matters More Now

The jewellery market is shifting. In June 2026, De Beers reported that wholesale prices for lab-grown diamonds had fallen 93% since 2020. As lab-grown stones become cheaper and easier to find, the question for shoppers is moving away from whether a gem looks perfect and towards what makes it worth owning at all.

With coloured gemstones, clarity is one factor among several. A ruby’s saturation, an emerald’s natural inclusions or a sapphire’s origin can shape its desirability as much as its cut. Some imperfections do reduce durability or value, while others record a stone’s geological history or give it a distinct character. Knowing the difference is the skill.

A Ruby That Is Not Eye-Clean

Stephanie Tan, founder of Singapore-based Equatorial Bespoke Jewellery, approaches this from two directions. She trained as a silversmith, and her work centres on natural coloured gemstones.

One stone from her personal collection makes the point. It is a 2.10-carat untreated ruby from Burma that is not completely eye-clean. What drew her to it was its vivid red colour, strong lustre, transparency and lively brilliance.

untreated Burmese ruby
A 2.10-carat untreated Burmese ruby from Stephanie Tan’s personal collection. Photo: Equatorial Bespoke Jewellery

For Tan, a stone’s overall character can matter more than any single technical criterion. There is a limit, though: inclusions that visibly reduce transparency or brilliance still lower a gem’s value.

When Seeing the Stone Changes the Brief

Seeing a gem in person can also change what a buyer thinks they want. Tan recalls a couple who came to her boutique looking for a natural colourless diamond, with fixed requirements for colour, clarity and cut.

During the appointment, one of them was drawn instead to an untreated parti-colour sapphire of more than three carats. The emerald-cut stone shows greenish-blue, yellow and green hues across its face.

parti-colour sapphire engagement ring
An untreated parti-colour sapphire of over three carats in an east-west 18k yellow gold bezel. Photo: Equatorial Bespoke Jewellery

Tan designed an east-west bezel setting in 18k yellow gold to frame those colours. The sapphire became the engagement ring, replacing the diamond the couple had planned to buy.

How to Judge Coloured Gemstones Beyond Their Looks

Much of Tan’s work is helping clients understand treatments, sourcing and setting, and how each one affects a stone’s fit for a design and a budget. Her advice for anyone shopping for coloured gemstones covers a few common misconceptions:

  • Inclusions are not automatically defects. Ask whether they affect transparency, brilliance or durability, not simply whether they are there.
  • Colour often leads value. Saturation and tone can matter more than a perfect clarity grade.
  • Treatment status changes price. An untreated stone and a heated or filled one of similar appearance are not priced the same.
  • A famous origin is not a guarantee. The individual stone still has to earn its price.
  • Lab reports have limits. They can confirm identity, treatments and, where determinable, geographic origin, but they cannot tell a buyer which stone will feel right to them.
Stephanie Tan, founder of Equatorial Bespoke Jewellery
Stephanie Tan, founder of Equatorial Bespoke Jewellery. Photo: Equatorial Bespoke Jewellery

The same applies when comparing natural and lab-grown options. Rarity, market value and individual character differ between the two, and understanding those differences leads to better buying decisions.

Two stones that look alike at first glance can differ sharply in rarity, character and value. As lab-grown alternatives keep getting cheaper, that may be the most useful lesson for anyone buying coloured gemstones today: the best choice is not always the one that looks most perfect on paper. For more on how consumers in the region are rethinking where their money goes, see our report on how Southeast Asia consumers are shifting to smarter spending.

Written by
Mei Ling

Mei Ling covers Growth & Capital for RiseAsia — venture capital and startup funding, FDI and trade, corporate expansion and market outlooks, following the money and deals shaping Asia's economies.